CrowdSens View the public consensus based on all participation.

Top 91 Pizza Restaurants in New York, NY

  • 1

    Village Pizza - (65 8th Ave New York, NY 10014) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 2

    Grimaldi's - (656 Avenue Of The Americas New York, NY 10010) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 3

    Mama Tinas Pizza - (2649 Frederick Douglass Blvd New York, NY 10030) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 4

    Two Boots West Village - (201 W 11th Street New York, NY 10014) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 5

    Little Italy Pizza & Deli - (180 Varick St New York, NY 10014) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 6

    Crispy pizza cafe - (114 7th Ave New York, NY 10011) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 7

    New Roma Pizza - (116 Delancey St New York, NY 10002) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 8

    Hana's Pizza - (1376 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10128) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 9

    Numero 28 Pizza - (1431 1st Ave New York, NY 10021) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 10

    iPizzaNY - (707 9th Ave New York, NY 10019) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 11

    Pastafina Pizza - (388 3rd Ave New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 12

    La Mia Pizza - (1488 1st Ave New York, NY 10075) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 13

    Patsy's Pizzeria - (206 E 60th St New York, NY 10022) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 14

    East Broadway Pizza - (181 E Broadway New York, NY 10002) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 15

    Pizza Petes - (528 Columbus Ave New York, NY 10024) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 16

    Inatteso Pizzabar Casano - (28 West St New York, NY 10004) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 17

    Pomodoro Pizza - (14 Rector St New York, NY 10006) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 18

    Brick Oven Pizza 33 - (268 W 23rd St New York, NY 10011) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 19

    Scarr's Pizza - (22 Orchard St New York, NY 10002) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 20

    Joey Pepperoni's Pizza - (493 2nd Ave New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 21

    The Big Slice - 5th Ave - (146 5th Ave New York, NY 10011) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 22

    Gruppo - (98 Avenue B New York, NY 10009) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 23

    Two Boots Hell's Kitchen - (625 9th Ave New York, NY 10036) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 24

    La Vera Pizza - (922 2nd Ave New York, NY 10017) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 25

    King's Pizza - (110 W 145th St New York, NY 10039) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 26

    Roses Pizza Pasta - (1 Penn Plz New York, NY 10119) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 27

    Lazzaras Pizza - (221 W 38th St New York, NY 10018) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 28

    Ben's Pizzeria - (123 Macdougal St New York, NY 10012) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 29

    2 Bros. Pizza - (542 9th Ave New York, NY 10018) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 30

    John's of Bleecker Street - (278 Bleecker St New York, NY 10014) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 31

    Mariella Pizza - (965 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10021) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 32

    Cafe Rustico II - (35 W 35th St New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 33

    Dona Bella Pizza - (154 Church Steet New York, NY 10007) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 34

    Grandpas Brick Oven Pizza - (4973 Broadway New York, NY 10034) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 35

    Famous Famiglia - (686 8th Ave New York, NY 10036) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 36

    Lil' Frankie's - (19 1st Ave New York, NY 10003) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 37

    Picasso Pizzeria - (303 S End Ave New York, NY 10280) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 38

    Toms Delicious Pizza - (3161 Broadway New York, NY 10027) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 39

    T R Pizza - (411 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 40

    Pastafina - (876 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10065) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 41

    Big Al's Chicago Style Pizza - (9 Thames St New York, NY 10006) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 42

    Papa John's Pizza - (703 Lenox Ave New York, NY 10039) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 43

    Fiores Pizza - (165 Bleecker St New York, NY 10012) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 44

    Grandmas Pizza - (2551 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10033) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 45

    Sofia Pizza Shoppe - (989 1st Ave New York, NY 10022) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 46

    Oxford Cafe - (591 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10022) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 47

    Posto - (310 2nd Ave New York, NY 10003) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 48

    Solo Pizza NYC - (27 Avenue B New York, NY 10009) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 49

    Garlic New York Pizza Bar - (629 2nd Ave New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 50

    New York Sal's Pizza - (696 10th Ave New York, NY 10019) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 51

    Muzzarella Pizza - (221 Avenue A New York, NY 10009) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 52

    Abitinos Pizzeria - (936 2nd Ave New York, NY 10022) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 53

    Pizza Haven - (4942 Broadway New York, NY 10034) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 54

    La Trattoria - (844 2nd Ave New York, NY 10017) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 55

    Don Filippo - (1133 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10075) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 56

    Proto's Pizza - (50 2nd Ave New York, NY 10003) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 57

    John & Tony's - (1097 1st Ave New York, NY 10065) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 58

    Harlem Pizza Co - (135 W 116th St New York, NY 10026) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 59

    Belmora Pizza & Restaurant - (139 E 57th St New York, NY 10022) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 60

    Da Vinci Pizza - (44 Water St New York, NY 10004) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 61

    Pomodoro Ristorante - (51 Spring St New York, NY 10012) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 62

    Lower East Side Pizza - (181 E Broadway New York, NY 10002) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 63

    Mozzarellis - (38 E 23rd St New York, NY 10010) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 64

    Pizza Stop - (531 Malcolm X Blvd New York, NY 10037) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 65

    Stromboli Pizza - (83 Saint Marks Pl New York, NY 10003) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 66

    Joey Pepperonis Pizza - (381 Broadway New York, NY 10013) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 67

    Georges Pizza - (726 W 181st St New York, NY 10033) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 68

    Pizza Beach - (167 Orchard St New York, NY 10002) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 69

    Pronto Pizza - (62 W 48th St New York, NY 10036) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 70

    Gotham Pizza - (852 8th Ave New York, NY 10019) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 71

    Caesars Palace Pizzeria - (493 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 72

    Pizza Da Solo - (550 Madison Ave New York, NY 10022) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 73

    Domino's Pizza - (181 Church St New York, NY 10007) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 74

    Pizza 33 - (489 3rd Ave New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 75

    Champion Pizza SoHo - (17 Cleveland Pl New York, NY 10012) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 76

    Salvos Pizzabar - (1477 York Ave New York, NY 10075) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 77

    Little Italy Pizza - (2 E 33rd St New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 78

    Baker's Pizza - (201 Avenue A New York, NY 10009) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 79

    Giuseppes Pizza - (341 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 80

    Famous Amadeus Pizza - (616 Amsterdam Ave New York, NY 10024) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 81

    Daniellos Pizzeria - (70 W 95th St New York, NY 10025) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 82

    Artichoke Basilles Pizza Bar - (114 10th Ave New York, NY 10011) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 83

    Librettos Pizzeria - (546 3rd Ave New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 84

    Famous Original Ray's Pizza - (1827 2nd Ave New York, NY 10128) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 85

    Iggy's Pizzeria - (173 1st Ave New York, NY 10003) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 86

    Sutton Pizza and Gyro - (1140 1st Ave New York, NY 10065) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 87

    LJ Pizza - (754 10th Ave New York, NY 10019) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 88

    Famous Original Rays Pizza - (811 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10065) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 89

    Royal Pizza - (592 3rd Ave New York, NY 10016) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 90

    Little Italy Gourmet Pizza - (11 Park Pl New York, NY 10007) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • 91

    New York Pizza Suprema - (413 8th Ave New York, NY 10001) map

    Like 0 people like this. 1 people use this response.
  • +

    Add More